There has been a lot of controversy about the recent amendment
to the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr., Hate Crimes Prevention Act, proposed by Republicans, that would
have specifically stated that pedophiles are not protected under that law. Republicans contend that pedophilia is not a
sexual orientation and therefore pedophiles cannot be victims of discrimination
based solely on their sexual preference.
House Democrats defeated the bill.
Rep. Alcee Hastings (D-Fl) apparently disagrees with the Republicans. He stated that all "alternative sexual
lifestyles" should be protected under the law. Really, Congressman? Do you have a young child?
Hastings stated “This bill addresses our resolve
to end violence based on prejudice and to guarantee that all Americans,
regardless of race, color, religion, national origin, gender, sexual
orientation, gender identity, or disability or all of these ‘philias’ and
fetishes and ‘isms’ that were put forward need not live in fear because of who
they are. I urge my colleagues to vote in favor of this rule.”
California Congresswoman, Rep. Jackie Speier CA (D), wants
to federalize a California state law to prohibit counseling to change a
person’s sexual orientation. That doesn’t sound that extreme, but pedophilia is
a sexual orientation according to that bill as well.
“This language is so broad and vague, it arguably could
include all forms of sexual orientation, including pedophilia,” said Brad
Dacus, president of the Pacific Justice Institute. “It’s not just the
orientation that is protected—the conduct associated with the orientation is
protected as well.”
So if pedophilia is classified as a sexual orientation, discrimination
laws also apply to pedophiles. That means you cannot block a pedophile from
being a preschool teacher or running a day care service or any other occupation
that would be high risk to children.
One can’t help but wonder why, if sexual assaults against
children are illegal, anyone would consider special protections for the people
who commit the crimes. Voting down the
bill did not legalize pedophilia but, as Mr. Dacus stated, it could open the
door to make prosecuting pedophiles more difficult.
And what happens if a rapist decides that he wants
non-consensual sex to be a “sexual orientation” or an “alternative lifestyle.” Will they be protected as well because they
are simply acting on their sexual orientation?
And where does it end?
There are two reasons that pedophilia cannot and must not be
considered a “sexual orientation.” First
is the fact that when sexual orientation is a consideration it is generally
deemed to be sexual practices between consenting adults. Non-consensual sexual contact (sexual
assault) is a crime regardless of whether it is gay or straight. Consent is the key word. Children, because of their emotional
immaturity and because of the law, cannot legally give their consent for sexual
contact.
The second reason is because sexual assault against a child
is still illegal – whether or not pedophilia is someday classified as a form of
sexual orientation. If it makes
Democrats feel better to pass a law that says pedophiles cannot be attacked
physically because of their deviant sexual desires then hey – pass that
law. After all - it's not illegal to have sexual desire for children if you never act on that desire. But if they pass a law that gives
pedophiles all the same protections as heteros, gays and transgenders, thus
allowing them easier access to children through their employment, living
arrangements, etc., and they do act on those desires, then the lawmakers themselves have that blood on their hands.
I’m thinking if Alcee Hastings or Jackie Speier had a young
child who was the object of desire for the pedophile living next door they
might feel differently about classifying pedophilia as a protected sexual
orientation. Pedophiles should live in fear. Every day. But then – who really knows
what goes on in the minds of most liberals?
While I do agree that Americans can't run around assaulting pedophiles on a regular basis just because of the crimes they commit, I can tell you with certainty that if they are granted
protection under the Hate Crimes Act you will see murders of pedophiles
increase. Parents are not going to sit
idly by and allow their children to be sexually assaulted with no chance of
justice. Mark my words.